A Place At the Table or Not
To Thanksgiving or Not Thanksgiving - This is The Question

There comes a point when knowing something changes what you can comfortably participate in.
You can spend years enjoying a holiday. You remember the smell of the kitchen, the particular dish your grandmother always made, the family arguments, the children running through the house, and the extraordinary pleasure of sitting down to a meal that somebody has spent two days preparing.
You may have wonderful memories of Thanksgiving.
You may still love it.
And then you learn more about the history.
You discover that the cheerful story you were taught about Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing a meal was a carefully sanitized account of a much larger history. You learn about the land that was taken, the treaties that were broken, the people who were murdered, the families separated, the cultures attacked, and the generations who inherited the consequences.
The gathering in 1621 was real. Wampanoag people and English colonists did share food. But the familiar story of friendship and national beginnings obscures the political circumstances surrounding that encounter and the violence that followed.
The holiday we celebrate today developed much later, and its history is more complicated than a single massacre or a single meal. But the national mythology surrounding Thanksgiving has helped generations of Americans remember colonial settlement without adequately confronting its consequences.
For many Indigenous people, Thanksgiving is a day of mourning. Since 1970, Native people and their allies have gathered in Plymouth, Massachusetts, for the National Day of Mourning.
Suddenly, the cheerful little paper Pilgrim hats we made in elementary school seem considerably less innocent.
So what do we do with that knowledge?
How do we sit down to a holiday meal when we can no longer separate the occasion from the history we've learned?
The answer might be that we don't.
I want to give that possibility the respect it deserves.
You are allowed to decide that Thanksgiving is no longer something you can celebrate. You are allowed to decline the invitation, cook an ordinary dinner, spend the day in quiet reflection, or participate in an observance that acknowledges Indigenous grief and survival.
You are allowed to say that something you once loved has become difficult to reconcile with your conscience.
You may also decide to sit at the table.
Perhaps your elderly mother is there, and the number of Thanksgivings you have left together is painfully finite.
Perhaps your children are coming home.
Perhaps your family has already stripped away the Pilgrim mythology, and the day has become an occasion for gratitude, generosity, and the complicated work of loving one another.
Perhaps you believe that gathering to give thanks is a human practice worth preserving, even while rejecting the mythology attached to this particular holiday.
I can understand that, too.
I don't believe there is one morally correct way for every person to navigate this.
But I do believe we owe ourselves the discomfort of making a conscious decision.
Because there is a difference between choosing something after careful reflection and continuing to participate simply because we've always done it.
There is another uncomfortable possibility worth considering.
We might be tempted to find a way to make Thanksgiving feel acceptable again as quickly as possible.
We can acknowledge the land. We can read an Indigenous author's poem. We can make a donation, change the decorations, and announce that our family now celebrates gratitude rather than colonialism.
Those things may be sincere and meaningful.
But I wonder whether we sometimes reach for a new ritual because we desperately want to stop feeling uncomfortable.
I don't want us to confuse acknowledging harm with having resolved our relationship to it.
An acknowledgment before dinner does not repair centuries of dispossession.
A donation does not erase the history.
Refusing to celebrate does not, by itself, create justice either.
Perhaps the discomfort is something we're meant to live with for a while.
Perhaps it should change more than one Thursday in November.
It might change what history we teach our children. Which Indigenous writers we read. Whose sovereignty we support. How we understand the land beneath our homes and the institutions that govern it.
It might lead us into relationships, responsibilities, and acts of solidarity that continue long after the leftovers are gone.
And perhaps it will lead us to reconsider other things we have accepted without much examination.
That is one of the difficult gifts of spiritual maturity.
Our understanding grows, and sometimes our old ways of living can no longer comfortably contain it.
We don't get to unknow what we know.
But we do get to decide how we live with that knowledge.
I also want to be careful about whose grief we center in this conversation.
Indigenous people are not a single community with a single relationship to Thanksgiving. Some celebrate it. Some reject it. Some observe a day of mourning. Some have family traditions that exist quite independently of the national mythology.
Their experiences deserve to be heard in their own voices.
Our discomfort about Thanksgiving should never become another occasion in which everyone talks about Indigenous people while failing to listen to them.
So this year, perhaps the spiritual work begins with listening.
Read the history. Listen to Indigenous people. Consider the choices available to you and the relationships those choices affect.
And then make a decision you can live with.
You may set the table.
You may leave an empty chair.
You may decide not to gather at all.
You may discover that you need a completely different ritual for gratitude, remembrance, and responsibility.
You may not know yet.
That's allowed, too.
There is no spiritual requirement to resolve a moral conflict in time for dinner.
At the Threshold, we talk often about living in conscious relationship with the sacred.
Sometimes that means lighting candles and offering blessings.
Sometimes it means looking at a tradition we have loved for decades and asking whether we can still participate with integrity.
And sometimes the most sacred thing we can do is admit that we haven't found our answer.
With love, solidarity, and a willingness to remain uncomfortable,
Lisa Hayes
Order of the Threshold | Threshold Ministries



